The Hidden Risks Behind Influencer Marketing (and How to Manage Them)

What Early Lawsuits Teach Us About Today’s Risks

Looking back at the early rise of digital creators, the legal foundation is clear: copyright infringement is a strict liability offense. That means intent doesn’t matter. A creator could have a genuine interest in using a trending audio clip, not realizing it’s copyrighted—but if it appears in sponsored content, both the influencer and the brand can be held legally responsible.

This can put marketers in a difficult position. With so many social media influencers posting across social media platforms, using background music, stock footage, memes, or GIFs, it’s easy to overlook proper usage rights. Yet one mistake can lead to damages of up to $150,000 per infringement.

How Copyright Missteps Turn Into High-Cost Brand Exposure

Consider a lifestyle brand partnering with a TikTok creator whose video unexpectedly went viral. The creator used an unlicensed audio track—common among many influencers, but still legally risky. When the copyright holder took action, the creator lacked the resources to respond, leaving the brand to settle the lawsuit at a substantial cost. This scenario is far from rare.

This is why smart marketers emphasize thoughtful vetting, proper licensing, and contractual safeguards. The better aligned the influencer marketing strategy is with the brand’s values and legal standards, the lower the chance of serious exposure.

When Copyright Claims Target the Brand, Not the Creator

Copyright holders have shifted their focus from creators to brands over the past decade—largely because brands have the funding to pay judgments. We call this the “deep pocket” reality. Two legal doctrines drive this trend:

1. Vicarious Liability: If a brand benefits financially from the content and has the ability to supervise or approve it, courts may find the brand responsible for the infringement.
2. Contributory Infringement: If a brand materially contributes to or encourages the creation of content, liability may follow—especially when the brand provides direction, funding, or creative assets.

Fashion labels, gaming companies, and lifestyle brands have all faced lawsuits stemming from influencer content using copyrighted music or clips. For instance, Sony Music sued DSW (Designer Shoe Warehouse) for “rampant infringement,” claiming that DSW and its paid influencers used over 120 Sony-owned recordings in TikTok and Instagram posts without proper licenses. Even when the influencer acted independently, the brand was still the main target. This shift illustrates why clear contracts, licensing requirements, and brand alignment matter more than ever before.

Additionally, brand collaborations can amplify both the reach and the risk of an influencer marketing campaign. If two brands partner on a cross-promotional campaign, one misstep by an influencer can affect multiple companies’ brand reputation, emphasizing the importance of precise contracts and internal compliance measures.

The Limits of Platform Policies—and What They Don’t Cover

Platforms like YouTube and Twitch may remove infringing content under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), but these “Safe Harbor” provisions protect the platform—not the creator or the sponsoring brand. A takedown might stop a video from circulating, but it doesn’t prevent a copyright holder from filing a federal lawsuit.

Marketers sometimes assume that the platform’s tools—Content ID, automated detection, etc.—are enough. They aren’t. Without internal processes for verifying rights and content sources, brands risk losing control of the narrative and damaging the brand’s credibility or even the entire brand’s reputation.

Platform rules, while helpful, cannot replace internal compliance. Brands must also ensure influencers engage in proper disclosure for sponsored posts and that campaigns comply with FTC regulations and other industry standards. This includes ensuring key collaborators clearly identify paid content, especially when targeting specific niches or multiple social media platforms.

How Generative AI Creates a New Wave of IP Risks for Brands

The introduction of Generative AI tools, such as Sora, Midjourney, ChatGPT, and others, has revolutionized how influencers engage with influencer content production. But they’ve also accelerated new forms of intellectual property (IP) risk.

Shadow Plagiarism

AI tools sometimes create outputs that unintentionally mimic copyrighted materials. An AI-generated graphic might appear original but resemble a professional illustration closely enough to raise claims. Without research, review, and licensing checks, brands could unknowingly distribute infringing works.

Ownership Uncertainty

AI-generated works are often not eligible for copyright protection in the US. If a brand commissions content built primarily by AI, the legal ownership becomes murky. Contracts must clearly define who owns what and how AI tools should be used in an effective influencer strategy.

Misattributed or Unlinked Content

AI can remix information without attribution, raising the possibility of plagiarized captions, scripts, or visuals. This can undermine consumer trust and expose the brand to claims.

Rising Legal Costs

AI-driven infringement cases are expensive, complex, and increasing rapidly. Brands must negotiate insurance language carefully, especially for campaigns involving brand collaborations or content that may appear across multiple platforms.

• Key takeaway: AI can amplify marketing efforts, but it also amplifies risks unless brands adopt review processes and clear guidelines.

Practical Risk Management for Influencer Marketing Campaigns

A reactive approach won’t cut it. Brands must integrate protections into creative workflows, contracts, and insurance.

Contractual & Operational Measures

• Mandatory IP Indemnification: Every influencer partnership should require that creators cover the brand for claims linked to their influencer content. This is essential whether you’re working with large creators, nano influencers, opinion leaders, or smaller free product–style partnerships.
• Clear AI Usage Policy: Define what tools creators may use and require human review for all AI-assisted media.
• Audit Trail & Documentation: Keep records of licenses, approvals, AI usage, and content submissions. Documentation protects the brand and proves due diligence if a claim arises.
• Training for Creators and Brand Ambassadors: Even seasoned creators don’t always understand IP law. Offering guidance helps mitigate risks, strengthen brand alignment, and reduce the chance of associating your brand with illegal behavior or campaigns that go viral for the wrong reasons.

Insurance Policies That Actually Matter

Insurance is essential—but only if coverage addresses modern realities like AI, influencer endorsements, and sponsored content.

Media Liability Insurance

Protects against copyright, trademark, and defamation claims. To address AI-related risks, brands should review media liability coverage and negotiate endorsements for influencer marketing campaigns or sponsored posts.

Directors & Officers (D&O) Liability

Executives can be named personally if stakeholders argue they failed to manage key risks tied to influencer campaigns. Reviewing D&O insurance ensures leadership is protected from claims arising from campaign oversight decisions.

Cyber Liability Insurance

While often associated with data breaches, certain cyber policies extend to claims involving unauthorized data use within AI tools. Brands should examine cyber liability insurance to understand coverage gaps—particularly as AI plays a bigger role in influencer marketing strategy and marketing efforts.

Operational Tips for Minimizing Risk While Maximizing Engagement

Working with influencers isn’t just about picking the ones with the biggest followers. It’s about understanding how each creator connects with their target audience and ensuring their influencer content reflects your brand’s message. Even small missteps—like an unlicensed image, misleading claim, or content that doesn’t align with your brand’s values—can lead to reputational damage or impact brand visibility. Planning campaigns thoughtfully from the start goes a long way in keeping your brand safe while still engaging your audience.

Clear communication is key. Take the time to set expectations with creators upfront, discuss sponsored content guidelines, and explain what types of content are off-limits. When creators understand your standards, it builds authentic engagement and helps avoid negative publicity down the line. This kind of collaboration fosters a deeper connection between the brand and its influencer’s audience, making the entire influencer marketing campaign stronger.

Here are ways you can put these principles into action:

• Integrate IP checks early, before content goes live.
• Use both human review and automated tools.
• Maintain a risk register of AI-assisted assets and licensing agreements.
• Work only with creators who demonstrate a genuine interest in your product and show natural brand alignment.
• Don’t rely solely on follower count—prioritize creators whose audiences match your target market and whose brand’s values mirror your own.
• Confirm that creators have not been involved in scandals, content theft, or behavior that could lead to negative aspects or reputational damage.

Even after a campaign is live, monitoring how influencers’ followers respond is critical. Keep an eye on feedback, audience engagement, and any changes in consumer behaviour or purchasing decisions. Brands that treat risk management as an ongoing part of their influencer marketing strategy—rather than a one-off step—are better positioned to mitigate risks, maintain consumer trust, and keep campaigns performing at their best.

Quick Wins and Core Lessons For Risk Leaders

Influencer marketing continues to deliver positive effects—from improving audience engagement to influencing purchasing decisions and boosting company sales. But with these rewards come significant, evolving risks.

To safeguard your brand:

• Enforce zero-tolerance policies for unapproved AI-generated content.
• Include IP indemnification clauses in every influencer partnership.
• Review Media Liability, D&O, and Cyber Liability coverage for AI-related exposures.
• Prioritize creators whose influencer content and values align with your own.

Remember: campaigns that feel authentic to your target audience create better connections and stronger success metrics.

A single oversight can transform a promising influencer marketing campaign into a costly problem. But with strong processes, thoughtful influencer partnerships, and the right insurance, brands can build high-performing influencer campaigns while minimizing exposure.

Partner With Founder Shield to Protect Your Influencer Strategy

Founder Shield helps brands build strong influencer programs while managing the unique risks of influencer marketing and digital/AI-driven influencer content. Our Media Liability Insurance protects against claims like copyright infringement, defamation, and other issues tied to sponsored content, influencer endorsements, and paid media campaigns—covering YouTubers, TikTok creators, and social media influencers alike.

We also offer Directors & Officers (D&O) Liability to safeguard executives overseeing influencer marketing strategy, and Cyber Liability Insurance for AI-assisted content and cross-platform campaigns. With these specialized coverages, thoughtful vetting, and clear contractual safeguards, brands can focus on audience engagement, brand visibility, and influencing purchasing decisions—while reducing reputational and legal risks.

Protect your campaigns—explore our media insurance solutions and schedule a consultation today.

Insurance Rebuilt, End-to-End

We've supported startups from stealth mode to huge funding rounds.

Get a Custom Quote